College Football: My Guilty Pleasure

College football has been taking some pretty hard hits lately. With disgruntled players considering unionizing and lawsuits over revenue sharing, I can no longer pretend it’s just a game. Ignoring the legal issues to focus on the field doesn’t help. Every bone-crushing tackle makes me cringe and worry about the serious risk of brain injury to the players.

Nevertheless, I confess: I can’t wait for Saturday. I’ll watch a full two hours of pre-game coverage and analysis on ESPN. I’ll proudly wear the Maize and Blue of my alma mater, University of Michigan. At kick-off, I’ll be in position in front of my 60-inch flat screen where I will remain – and there will be silence – until the clock reads 00:00.

But I won’t feel entirely good about it. College football has become a guilty pleasure.

I used to watch games with such joyful and overwhelming enthusiasm – the sport was all about school spirit, athleticism, and sportsmanship – not to mention promising young men earning college degrees while taking the field for the love of the game. What’s not to like?

Plenty, according to recent media coverage.

In April, the National Labor Relations Board voted that Northwestern University football players are employees rather than students, and can vote to unionize.

By late summer, a federal judge ruled that the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) couldn’t prevent athletes from selling rights to their names and images, essentially opening the door for them to be paid to play.

Worst of all, new research on brain injuries indicates that even college football players who don’t suffer concussions show changes in brain structure and cognitive performance. I have never jumped for joy when an opposing player limps off the field, but now I can’t even celebrate the big plays in which no one appears to get hurt.

I’m not sure how I will get through Saturday’s festivities. Beer may help.

But I don’t buy that all the news is bad.

I still believe football players are not employees but student athletes – and the “student“ part comes first. The data back me up: Division 1 football players have a 71% Graduation Success Rate (a percentage which outperforms their non-athlete peers and has been increasing).

As for “pay to play,” it’s not necessary. Scholarship athletes often get accepted to universities they could never attend on their credentials alone – a priceless benefit by itself, not to mention free tuition, room, and board. Of course some football teams earn money for their schools, but individual contributions are negligible. If the top 2 players from every Division 1 football program dropped out tomorrow, those schools would not lose a cent of revenue.

So I don’t feel guilty because players aren’t really receiving an education (they are) or because they aren’t properly compensated for their contributions (again, they are). The head injury risk is harder to get over.

All of us who watch football expect to see injuries sometimes – it’s a rough game, but sprained ankles and torn ACL’s will heal. The brain, however, is tricky. Best-case scenario, a player with brain injuries sometimes loses his keys or has moments of forgetfulness. Worst case, he suffers from chronic traumatic encephalopathy and its terrible symptoms like depression, aggression, and dementia.

Can anyone enjoy watching football anymore?

I intend to try on Saturday. My school spirit is still strong and my heart will beat faster when the marching band (of which I was a proud member at Michigan) plays the fight song. I can’t not watch. I will feel a little guilty for liking it.

Advances in helmet technology, brain injury research, and even changes to game rules may alleviate some of the risk (and also my guilt) in the future. I sincerely hope it does, because I love my college football.

But players’ brains are more important.



2 thoughts on “College Football: My Guilty Pleasure

  1. Liz Hiser

    Great piece, Laura. While I’ve never been a football fanatic (I reserve that for baseball, from Little League to MLB), I’ve watched, followed and attended my share of college and Pro games since using my offering money at Sunday School to bet on the Redskins (Read: against the Dolphins) on Super Bowl Sunday 1973. Lately, though, I find myself disinterested in the game. I find myself over-reacting negatively to the rabid fan postings of my FB friends and Twitter follows. What changed? My son started playing hs football last year. And sustained his first concussion last year, too. Trust me, it is different when you have skin–almost literally–in the game. At this point I’m not all that worried about whether he should join the union at Northwestern or elsewhere, I’m operating week-to-week. Phew! Made it out of the pre-season scrimmage vs Needham. One down twelve (+/-) to go until Thanksgiving. Then, because he loves it so and turns out he’s not bad at it, my state of high alert during games and dull worry in between Friday nights will start all over again the following August.

    So, in many ways I envy your ability to root for the Maize & Blue full throttle. I hope one day to be back in that category, for some football team or another. Once my son’s playing career is over and I can watch a clean, hard hit without cringing (I hope).

    1. lmctaggart2013 Post author

      Thank you for your comment, Liz! I hope your son has a winning and injury-free season. Our nephew is a senior in HS and will likely play football in college…I do worry about his health all the time. It’s very hard on the body. I’m always amazed when players walk off the field after collisions that would certainly put me in the grave! To be young!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s