Won’t Anyone Think of the Children?

That’s what the state of Michigan is asking in a Detroit federal court case this week.  The children in question are being raised by two mothers who can’t marry each other (due to Michigan’s ban on same-sex marriage) and therefore can’t jointly adopt the children.

The state, defending its current law, wields a controversial and widely discredited study which claims that gay parents are bad for kids.  The paper is controversial because it takes some pretty big liberties with scientific best practices.  The research itself could be the subject of an 800-word rant, so for today I’ll stick to the definitive question being raised by this case: should parenting ability (or lack thereof) be a determining factor in a couple’s legal right to marry?


I remember applying for my marriage license in Michigan many years ago.  It wasn’t like applying for college or a job – this was a sure thing!  Marriage license applications had a 100% acceptance rate.   The clerk wasn’t looking askance at me, wondering if I’d be a good parent someday, and the law didn’t require any proof of such a thing.

Let’s admit that all kinds of riff-raff get married in this country – including people who may become terrible parents.  Marriage is legal for convicted criminals, people who have terminal diseases, and people who think Disney World makes for a romantic honeymoon destination.

disney couple

Half the married couples I know wouldn’t be married if “studies show you’ll be a great parent” were a required box on the married license.  That would rule out people who yell at the refs during sporting events, people who sneak into the express check-out line with 11 items (cheaters!), and anyone who doesn’t want a puppy.  The list of the unmarriageable would include (but is certainly not limited to):

  • Candy Crush addicts
  • Consumers of junk food
  • Anyone who watches too much TV
  • Those who are afraid of clowns
  • Disposable diaper advocates
  • Late sleepers
  • High-functioning alcoholics (then who would run the PTO?)
  • People who don’t compost or sort their recycling
  • New York Times subscribers (takes too long to read)
  • Frequent McDonalds customers
  • Residents of poor school districts
  • Ohio State fans (poor judgment)
  • Anyone in Mississippi (obviously)
  • Men who forget to put the seat down
  • Women who wear too much perfume
  • Renters of houses that have lead paint on the walls
  • Renters
  • Anyone whose sense of style and personal aesthetics prevent ownership of a minivan


Here’s what I think of the children: the ones in the current Michigan court case are lucky indeed. They have been chosen by a loving couple because their birth parents can’t care for them.  One of the little boys has disabilities that may prevent him from ever walking, talking, or feeding himself.

So I have a hard time conjuring a mental image of “better” parents than the women in this court case, who have voluntarily signed up for the toughest kind of parenting.  Two three-year-olds and a four-year-old!  I’m exhausted just looking at a sweet picture of them.

The family at the center of the Michigan case for marriage equality

If being a dedicated, loving parent becomes a condition for marriage in Michigan, approving this couple’s marriage license is a no-brainier. The state should pay for the wedding and give them a free honeymoon trip to Mackinac Island (a legitimate destination for excellent parents).

Good luck, state of Michigan, if this is particular case is your best shot at convincing the judge that gay parents aren’t as good for kids as heterosexual parents.  It may be an uphill battle with these particular plaintiffs.

For goodness’ sake, think of the children!

2 thoughts on “Won’t Anyone Think of the Children?

  1. Diane Rose

    very well put…. you are an amazing writer… Uncle Tom enjoyed it as much as I did .. Thanks for sending this. such clever reasons… like that OHIO STATE FAN LOL Love Aunt Diane

    Date: Tue, 4 Mar 2014 21:30:20 +0000 To: sportygal@hotmail.com

  2. Aileen

    I love your use of humor and the list of reasons made me chuckle, especially the minivan one – our family certainly does not look like that and our car is always dirty.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s